India’s one-off Test against Afghanistan at the New PCA Stadium in Mullanpur arrives at a peculiar crossroads — a fixture that, on paper, looks routine, but in reality carries the weight of an entire red-ball reset.
With the World Test Championship cycle ticking and an August tour of Sri Lanka already casting a long shadow, this match is far more than a standalone occasion for Shubman Gill’s side.
A Wound That Has Not Healed
India’s home Test record has taken a battering in recent memory. The 0-2 series capitulation to South Africa last November remains the most visible scar, one that has clearly unsettled the backroom staff under head coach Gautam Gambhir.
Gambhir, speaking to reporters on match eve, was candid about the lessons drawn from that defeat. “The one thing we have realised is that we need to start preparing better in red ball cricket,” he said. “That was something which was lacking against the West Indies and also against South Africa, that we have got to do going forward.”
It is a frank admission from a coaching unit that has been in transition mode since Gambhir’s appointment. While the tour of England last year offered what Gambhir described as a significant transitional milestone for this young Test group, a home series loss to South Africa served as a stark reminder of the gap between promise and reliability.
The Spinner Question India Cannot Ignore
Perhaps the most consequential subplot heading into this Test is India’s search for their next frontline spinner — and specifically, a left-arm option capable of filling the enormous shoes left by Ravindra Jadeja in his absence.
Two names have emerged as serious contenders: Manav Suthar and Harsh Dubey. One of them is set to earn a maiden Test cap at Mullanpur.
The two offer contrasting but complementary profiles. Suthar’s primary asset is reliability — a repeatable action that consistently produces wickets. Dubey, meanwhile, brings pronounced drift and a clever use of the crease that observers have likened to Jadeja’s own craft.
Gambhir did not reveal his hand publicly, but his reasoning offered a clear window into the decision-making process. “You don’t only see that they are two left-handers, but you also see the release points, what someone gets off the wicket, the trajectories and who is probably more suited for red ball cricket,” he said.
The stakes extend beyond this Test alone. With India likely to deploy a fourth spinner on the turning surfaces of Sri Lanka, the debutant here could be cementing a place in that touring party. The decision carries genuine medium-term consequences.
Sai Sudharsan and the Number Three Problem
The No. 3 batting position has become something of a revolving door in Indian Test cricket over the past two years, with seven different players trialled in that slot. That instability has frustrated selectors and analysts alike.
Management appears to have made a decision, even if they have stopped short of declaring it publicly. Sai Sudharsan, despite a mixed introduction to Test cricket in 2025, is set to be given a continued run ahead of the returning Devdutt Padikkal.
Gambhir was clear in his backing for the Tamil Nadu left-hander. “It’s not about giving someone five Tests and someone else one Test match. If we give someone a fair run, we will give the other guy a fair run as well whenever he gets the opportunity. But at the moment, I think we’ve got to give Sai a fair run,” he said.
It is a reasonable and defensible stance. Consistency of selection has historically been a hallmark of successful Test teams, and India’s churn at three has arguably cost the team more than any individual failure.
Rishabh Pant’s New Reality
No subplot at Mullanpur generates more discussion than Rishabh Pant’s altered role in this Test squad. Entering his 50th Test appearance, India’s most prolific six-hitter arrives without the vice-captaincy — a demotion that followed a match in Guwahati last year where his impetuous batting drew widespread criticism.
Pant’s batting in the nets at the secondary training facility appeared measured. An eagle-eyed Gambhir watched closely from behind the net as the wicketkeeper worked on vertical shots and a more compact defensive technique.
The message from management, though, is not one of curtailment. “We will expect him to be the way he is. We aren’t telling him to curb his natural game. But in international cricket, it’s very important to read the situation and play your shots accordingly,” Gambhir said.
It is a nuanced instruction — keep the flair, develop the judgement. Whether Pant, now six maximums short of 100 Test sixes, can reconcile those two demands consistently will define much of his legacy in the format.
Also Read : India T20I Captain: Who Replaces Suryakumar Yadav?
What Afghanistan Bring to the Table
It would be a mistake to dismiss the visitors as mere cannon fodder. Afghanistan arrive as a nation with only eight years of Test cricket behind them and a collective record of 12 Tests — but their white-ball credibility and the depth within Hashmatullah Shahidi’s squad suggest a team capable of creating genuine difficulties.
Their resources for this match are not without limitation, with several prominent white-ball names absent. Yet even local net bowlers working with the Afghanistan squad ahead of the Test came away impressed by the variety on show. That counts for something when conditions in sub-continental heat can humble any batting line-up.
What This Means for the WTC Cycle
This Test sits at an inflection point in India’s World Test Championship campaign. With a tour of Sri Lanka in August followed by a home Border-Gavaskar Trophy series against Australia in early 2027 on the WTC horizon, the margin for error in the coming months is shrinking.
The Sri Lanka tour, in particular, demands a settled and tested spinner combination. A red-ball series on turning pitches abroad will expose any gaps in India’s spin depth far more ruthlessly than a home game ever can.
Getting Sudharsan settled at No. 3, finding their best spinner combination, and recalibrating Pant’s role are not peripheral concerns — they are foundational ones. India need answers before the calendar demands results.
What Happens Next
The debutant spinner selected at Mullanpur will almost certainly feature in India’s planning for Sri Lanka, making their performance here a direct audition for a more demanding stage. Suthar or Dubey — whichever Gambhir backs — will face close scrutiny well beyond this one occasion.
Pant, meanwhile, enters a stretch of Test cricket that could genuinely reshape his legacy in the format. Fifty Tests in, still electric, but now with a specific brief: impose yourself within the situation, not against it.
FAQ
Why is the India vs Afghanistan Test significant for the WTC? The Test gives India a rare mid-cycle opportunity to trial combinations and settle positions ahead of challenging WTC fixtures in Sri Lanka and against Australia. Points from the match also contribute directly to the WTC standings.
Who is likely to debut for India as a spinner against Afghanistan? Either Manav Suthar or Harsh Dubey is expected to earn their first Test cap. Both are left-arm spinners; the final decision rests with head coach Gautam Gambhir and will likely shape future selections for the Sri Lanka tour.
Why has Rishabh Pant been demoted for the Afghanistan Test? Pant has been stripped of the vice-captaincy following his dismissal in Guwahati last year, which was widely criticised as reckless. Management have retained faith in his attacking instincts but have issued a clear directive for him to read match situations more carefully.
Is Sai Sudharsan confirmed to bat at No. 3 for India? While not officially confirmed, Gautam Gambhir’s comments on match eve strongly indicate that Sudharsan will continue at No. 3 ahead of Devdutt Padikkal, with the management backing him for a sustained run in the role.
When do India tour Sri Lanka for their next Test series? India are scheduled to tour Sri Lanka in August 2025, with the series forming part of the ongoing World Test Championship cycle.
1 thought on “India vs Afghanistan Test: What’s Really at Stake at Mullanpur”